Tragedy follows tragedy: Korach 5785

Tragedy follows tragedy in the book of Bamidbar. The unwarranted complaints of the people regarding the food in the desert and the false report regarding the Land of Israel (discussed in last week’s parsha) end in plague, punishment and disaster. This week’s parsha describes the rebellion of Korach and his cohorts against Moshe and the supremacy of Torah within Jewish society.

It seems that a latent death wish lurks within Jewish society which makes it repeat terrible mistakes. The generation of the desert saw miracles, even God’s presence, so to speak, on a regular basis. Yet it increasingly defied and rebelled against its special role in human civilization. This was really an expression of regret on the part of many Jews in the desert that they accepted the Torah carte blanche at Sinai. This group did not intend to be a chosen people. The plaintive cry of “let us just return to Egypt” is really a demand that “we wish to be just like all other peoples!” This cry has  repeated itself in almost every generation. The struggle within Jews and Jewish society through the ages is whether to accept its God-given role as a “treasure amongst all nations” or to somehow renounce all pretense of being a special people. The choices are not really portrayed as being that stark because we make them in a continuum of Jewish observance, where adherence to Jewish values and the willin
gnes s to remain proudly Jewish is a decision made in a world that is hostile to Jews, a Jewish state and Judaism itself. 

Korach has personal animosity towards Moshe and he is frustrated at not achieving the recognition that he feels is due him, yet he wraps these feelings within a cloak of holiness and altruism. Hypocrisy abounds, especially amongst those who judge others, and the self-righteous give righteousness a bad name. Korach claims, in the name of democracy, that all the people are holy and worthy of leadership. His claims resound with classical correctness. They are hard to argue against and certainly have great public resonance and appeal. The problem with Korach’s appeal and words is that they are basically fraudulent. 

Moshe’s status, determined by God, has been vindicated in Jewish history throughout the ages. While there are no truly unbiased people in the world, t there are those who, at the very least, recognize their bias and attempt to deal with it honestly and intelligently. Hypocrisy is the attempt to cover up one’s bias with false nobility of purpose and affected altruism. It is a reprehensible character trait, far greater in potential destructiveness than is open enmity itself. This is what made Korach so dangerous and why Moshe’s determination to publicly expose and punish him was so strident and insistent. The tragedy of Korach lies not only his own personal downfall but rather in the havoc and confusion that it created in Jewish society. It is a situation that repeats itself today as well. 

Shabbat shalom, Rabbi Berel Wein

Read "The Drive for Power", Rabbi Wein's devar Torah for Korach last year, here.

The Drive for Power: Korach 5784

Ramban (Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman) generally holds that the events recorded in the Torah occurred in a linear timeline, despite the maxim that there is no ‘before’ or ‘after’ in the Torah. So according to Ramban the story of Korach and his contest against Moshe—the central part of this week’s parsha—must have happened after the tragedy of the spies and their negative report about the Land of Israel.

 As I have commented before, the negative report of the spies was motivated, according to rabbinic opinion, by personal interests that had no objective value concerning the Land of Israel itself. So too, the uprising Korach led against Moshe concerns neither justice nor objective benefit to the people; rather, it was driven purely by personal issues and by the jealousies of Korach and his followers. 

Both Korach and the spies before him masked their own personal drives for power and position with high-sounding principles of public good, social justice and great concern for the future of the people of Israel. The very shrillness of their concern for the good of society itself calls attention to their true motives—they protested too much! Pious disclaimers of self-interest always seem to accompany those that clamor for greater justice and a better world. Dictators in the past and present centuries have promised great improvements for their nations—yet all, without exception, eventually pursued only their own personal gain and power. Beware of those who speak in the name of the people. They are mostly only imitations of Korach. 

This insight might explain why Moshe took such a strong stand against Korach and demanded an exemplary punishment from Heaven. It is extremely difficult for humans to judge the true motives of others in their declarations and policies. Only Heaven, so to speak, can do so. Moshe’s plea to Heaven is directed not only against the current Korach that he faces, but also against the constant recurrence of other Korachs throughout Jewish and world history. 

Only the shocking miracles of the earth swallowing Korach and his followers, and of a fire consuming those who dared to offer incense in place of Aharon, would impress upon the historical psyche of Israel the paramount need to be wary of Korach’s imitators through the ages. 

There is an adage in Jewish life that one should always respect others while remaining wary of their true motives. Only regarding Moshe does the Torah testify that, as the true servant of God, he is above criticism and suspicion. But ordinary mortals have ordinary failings—and self-interest is one of them. Moshe is true and his Torah is true. After that, no matter how fetching the slogan or how glorious the promise, caution and wariness about the person and cause being advocated are the proper attitudes to embrace. 

Shabbat shalom, Rabbi Berel Wein