The Long View: Redemption Through Setbacks

This piece was first posted on Hanassi Highlights, 15 January 2026.

If the opening of Parshat Va’era feels strangely familiar, it is not by coincidence. Once again, Hashem appears to Moshe with the words “Ani Hashem.” Once again, Moshe hesitates, describing himself as arel sefatayim, unable to speak. Once again, Aharon is appointed to stand at his side. The scene echoes almost word for word the encounter at the burning bush in last week’s parsha.

The Torah does not repeat itself without purpose. What, then, has changed?

Between the two conversations lies Moshe’s first failed attempt at redemption. Sent by Hashem to Pharaoh, Moshe demands freedom for Bnei Yisrael—and the result is devastating. Not only are the people not released; their suffering intensifies. Straw is removed, the workload increases, and despair deepens. Moshe turns back to Hashem in anguish: “Lama hare’ota la’am hazeh?” – Why have You made things worse for this people?

At that moment, it would have been natural to conclude that the mission had failed. That redemption had been attempted—and rejected. But Parshat Va’era opens by telling us otherwise. Hashem sends Moshe back. Not with a new plan, but with the same mission. The message is subtle yet profound: a setback is not the end of the story. What looks like failure may be part of a longer process, invisible in the moment but essential in retrospect. Chazal even suggest that the intensification of the labour contributed to shortening the exile. What felt like regression was, in truth, a step forward.

Sefer Shemot, like Sefer Bereishit before it, establishes a pattern. Just as the experiences of our Avot became a template for future generations, the first redemption from Egypt becomes the model for all redemptions that follow—complex, uneven, and unfolding in stages.

That insight speaks powerfully to our own moment. We live with profound emotional complexity: joy at moments of light alongside fear, grief, and uncertainty. The Torah does not ask us to deny that tension. On the contrary, it teaches us to hold it honestly. To give thanks for what has been achieved, even as we continue to pray for what is still incomplete.

This idea is reflected in the four expressions of redemption at the beginning of our parsha—the source of the four cups of wine at the Seder. The Yerushalmi understands them not as four poetic phrases, but as four distinct redemptive stages, each deserving gratitude in its own right, even as the process remains incomplete.

Parshat Vaera reminds us that redemption is not a single dramatic moment, but a journey. “Atah tireh,” Hashem tells Moshe—you will yet see. There is a larger plan, a broader horizon, and a story still unfolding. Our task is to remain steadfast, grateful, faithful and confident that, just as we were redeemed once, we will be redeemed fully again.

Shabbat Shalom!

To read this piece in Ivrit: click here.